Lavesh v. State of Haryana
Rule established
Proclamation and attachment under S.82/83 CrPC (now S.84/85 BNSS) require strict compliance with prescribed procedure. Attachment without valid proclamation or before expiry of the stipulated time is illegal.
Facts
- The accused was declared a proclaimed offender under S.82 CrPC and his property was attached under S.83.
- He challenged the proceedings arguing that the required procedures were not followed: the proclamation was not published as mandated, and attachment was ordered before the stipulated period had expired.
- The court examined the mandatory nature of compliance with S.82-83 CrPC.
Issues
- Whether the provisions of S.82-83 CrPC (S.84-85 BNSS) regarding proclamation and attachment are mandatory or directory?
- What are the consequences of non-compliance with the prescribed procedure?
Held
- The provisions of S.82 CrPC (S.84 BNSS) regarding proclamation are mandatory:
- Proclamation must be published by affixture at a conspicuous place in the accused's residence
- Read in a conspicuous place of the town
- Published in a local newspaper (if court directs)
- The 30-day period prescribed in S.82 must expire before attachment under S.83 can be ordered.
Ratio Decidendi
Proceedings for proclamation and attachment of property of absconding accused are quasi-penal in nature. They affect fundamental rights and must therefore be strictly construed. Non-compliance with mandatory requirements renders the proceedings a nullity.
How to use it in an exam
- Part A (6 marks): Cite for proclamation procedure (S.84 BNSS) and mandatory compliance. Key line: "Proclamation and attachment provisions are mandatory, not directory."
- Part B (15 marks): Useful for: (a) S.84-85 BNSS analysis (procedure, timeline, safeguards), (b) distinction between proclaimed offender and absconder, (c) rights of accused in absentia.
Source
Source: SCC
This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.
Cited in study notes
Proclamation and Attachment of PropertyMandatory compliance with proclamation procedure